Sunday, August 9, 2009

Readings for week 2

I think the two key points to remember from this weeks readings were how public relations don´t have a clear definition, and that the diverse theories of public relations focus on different parts of the communication process. The disagreement of what public relations really is, can create a debate around the ethics of the field. Different theories try to understand how public relations work and the effect it has on the public and vice versa.

Public relations can be valuable in many fields like management, advertising or politics. The readings made me think more about public relations theory in that the whole process of PR work can be evaluated differently depending on the theory and the context and situation of the public relations. For example the symmetrical/excellence theory focus on the connection between the organization and the public. The public isn´t just a passive mass but can give demands to the organization and it´s reputation. This is taken further by the situational theory, which focus on the different types of publics. Often this kind of evaluation can lead to ethical questions concerned with how a dominant organization best can get their agenda through. But it can also uncover social unfairness, as diverging groups are treated differently.

Some academics or public relations workers prefer to distance the PR business from the more negatively loaded word “propaganda”, which often don´t have ethical support. Others see a link between the two in their goal to make an effect on, or persuade, the public. One of the so-called “fathers” of public relations, Edward Bernays, used public relations for his campaigns after the war to avoid the bad connotations connected to propaganda.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Maren,
    I thought the points you made about the ethical considerations of PR were really interesting (and relevant for one of the debate topics). Particularly with your comment about social inequalities where "diverging groups are treated differently", do you think that this is in some ways important? I think that the industry really needs to have an acute understanding of society and their wants and needs, especially, as you noted, since we as the 'public' are not passive and therefore PR specialists need to be responsive to these.
    In saying this, maybe recognising these differences are a good thing, for instance, if we are trying to access a group of adolescent males who are really into football, although we must consider that we act in an ethical and morally just way, you wouldn't present the same thing to them as you would to a group of females. Maybe this would be considered sexist but at the end of the day, we are achieving the "interpreting (of) public opinion" and intentionally representing certain ideas as discussed in the lecture.
    Just a thought!
    Laura.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Laura!

    I think it must be a challenge for the PR practitioner to communicate in a manner that is understood by a diverging public. In order for a wide rage of people to understand a message in a some what equal way, I guess it could be useful to use a simple language to avoid misinterpretations. If special terms are used, or the language is difficult to understand, some groups may feel left out.
    I agree that it can be useful to adjust a message to a target public to achieve the most effective communication. In that way I wouldn't consider your example sexist.

    Thanks for your comment!
    Maren

    ReplyDelete